First, lets look at the newest example of K-Pop to come out:
I'm not going to analyze the musical content, because that's just a waste of time. It's drivel, but to be honest, I can deal with a lot of drivel. Drivel isn't what bothers me; it's everything else around it. Honestly, they could probably be singing Rogers and Hammerstein and I don't think anyone would know the difference.
The thing that really bothers me is the over-the-top theme of "I'm a slut, but I'm innocent." This drives me nuts. Listen, if you're going to be a slut, good for you. Be a slut. If you're going to go the innocent route, kudos. But the slutty and innocent thing wears thin, especially when it is during the whole video. I can see the record execs now: "The girls will like them because they are cute. The boys will like them because they want to have sex with them. We're geniuses!"
Admittedly, there are also K-Pop boy bands, like so:
Ok, this song is actually a little better. But that's a little like saying waterboarding is a little better than the iron maiden. Now, instead of a bunch of girls, it's a bunch of guys. Other than that, it's pretty much the same thing, except that I can see less leg.
It's not like I go looking for K-Pop music, either. It just comes to me. It's blaring from the corner store. It's on in every restaurant. If I want to buy something, it's guaranteed to be on the PA system in the store. And of course, a bar wouldn't be complete without some girl band music in the background.
Overall, the feeling that I get is an enormous feeling of conformity. I feel like it's saying "Look! We have 9-10 people doing the exact same thing and who look interchangeable. You can do it too." And it works. If you go to any street corner and start singing "Sorry, Sorry", I guarantee everyone around you will start doing the same dance. There are even online competitions where middle-aged dudes in suits film themselves doing the same dances. I get it. We're all the same. Be the same. Conform, or look like a wierdo.
Maybe I'm not looking in the right places, but where are the guys with long hair and tatoos? Where's the angst? Where's the rebellion? Damn it, Korean kids, get some guitars, turn 'em up and let's hear it!



We're silly and adventurous, computer geeks and yoga peeps.
February 04, 2010
bessie
February 04, 2010
Kristine
This all sounds like Britney Spears and techno had an extremely deranged baby. Interesting but I can see how it can get old really quickly.
Interesting comment about the "we're innocent, but we're kinda slutty too" angle. I think we get a lot of that here in the states too. We want the girls to be innocent and sweet but secretly (or not so secretly) we want them to be every man's fantasy. No wonder girls grow up with mixed messages. I can't imagine being a teenager in Korea.
February 05, 2010
Kyle
February 24, 2010
Linda